Can a Socratic Seminar be used in a mathematics classroom? PartII

The idea that Socratic seminar is more applicable to english, social studies, and history classrooms derives from our understanding of what learning looks like in these particular classrooms.  We would agree that an engaging discussion that represents two different viewpoints could occur in this context.  One might say that you cannot have a Socratic seminar in a math class because there is always one correct answer and an incorrect answer can not be argued effectively.  I believe that it would be counter productive to have a discussion in a math classroom that leads the students to accept wrong answers.  What I am proposing is that there are MANY different ways to arrive at the same answer in mathematics.  These different ways of reasoning would be the content of a mathematical Socratic seminar.  A Socratic seminar would be a great way to get the students to analyze math logic.  Students would not only learn from correct answers but also be able to discern between correct and incorrect steps that lead to wrong answers.  I assert that a Socratic seminar would facilitate high order thinking in a math classroom.

Can a Socratic Seminar be used in a mathematics classroom?

I think that the idea of a Socratic seminar is powerful.  It gives license to students to create knowledge and understanding.   It also contradicts the notion of a teacher as sole knowledge giver.  Several readings have demonstrated the effectiveness of the Socratic seminar in non-science classrooms.  However, can we really use this with math?  I think the answer to this question is YES.  Think of the book Teaching Problems and the Problems of Teaching by Magdalene Lampert.  Her method of teaching allows students to present different points about math problems like a Socratic seminar.  The moral of the story is: We should not underestimate the applicability of great teaching techniques to mathematics.

Debate: Technology in the Classroom

Technology in the classroom is a great idea and almost essential for our children to meet the demands of the 21st century.  However, when is technology inappropriate in the classroom?  There are free online polls that can be utilized in a classroom via text messaging.  Twitter has also been used in educational settings.  This sounds positive.  However, this type of technology usage can open up a can of worms in the form of learning distractions.  Internet in the classroom can result in children surfing the internet in class or playing online games.  Cell phone usage in the classroom could result in children texting messages to their friends during class time.  There are many schools that prohibit the use of cell phones during school hours.  By doing so, are these schools missing out on an untapped educational resource?  Where do you stand on this issue?

Resources in My Future Classroom

As a future mathematics teacher, there are certain resources that I would like to have in my classroom.  I would like to have a laptop for myself and all of my students.  I would also like to have  mathematical software.  I would also like a rolling white board, black board, projector, sound system, microphone, wireless internet, and a laser pointer.  I want my students to be technologically knowledgeable because we are entering a new era of advanced developments.  I also want students to be engaged in mathematics.  I believe that presenting class material to my students in multiple forms will help to differentiate my instruction effectively.  However, I know that my list of resources is very optimistic.  This is impossible for many inner city schools to accomplish.  I think that my first priority as a teacher will be to make sure that my students have basic resources such as good textbooks, writing utensils, etc. before trying to obtain some of high tech resources that I would prefer.

My First Post

This page is dedicated to exploring mathematics education and education in general. I will be posting my thoughts and comments about education issues that are relevant in today's society.